Edward L. Doheny

Edward L. Doheny
Doheny, 1920s
Born	Edward Laurence Doheny (1852-09-14)September 14, 1852 Fond du Lac, Wisconsin, U.S.
Died	September 9, 1935(1935-09-09) (aged 82) Los Angeles, California, U.S.
Occupations	Miner prospector driller businessman philanthropist
Spouses	Mary Elizabeth O'Donnell (1884) Margaret R. McFadden (1916)
Children	5

Edward Laurence Doheny (/doʊˈhiːni/; September 14, 1852 – September 9, 1935) was an American oil tycoon who, in 1892, drilled the first successful oil well in the Los Angeles City Oil Field. His success set off a petroleum boom in Southern California, and made him a fortune when, in 1902, he sold his properties.

He then began highly profitable oil operations in Tampico, Mexico's "golden belt", drilling the first well in the nation in 1901. He expanded operations during the Mexican Revolution, and opened large new oil fields in Lake Maracaibo (Venezuela). His holdings developed as the Pan American Petroleum & Transport Company, one of the largest oil companies in the world in the 1920s.

In the 1920s, Doheny was implicated in the Teapot Dome scandal and accused of offering a $100,000 bribe to United States Secretary of the Interior Albert Fall.^[1] Doheny was twice acquitted of offering the bribe, but Fall was convicted of accepting it. Doheny and his second wife and widow, Margaret McFadden, were noted philanthropists in Los Angeles, especially regarding Catholic schools, churches and charities. The character J. Arnold Ross in Upton Sinclair's 1926-27 novel Oil! (the inspiration for the 2007 film There Will Be Blood) is loosely based on Doheny.

Edward L. Doheny was born in 1856 in Fond du Lac, Wisconsin,^[1] to Patrick "Pat" and Eleanor Elizabeth "Ellen" (née Quigley) Doheny. The family was Irish Catholic. His father was born in Ireland, and fled County Tipperary in the wake of the Great Famine. Patrick tried whaling after reaching Labrador.^[2] His mother was born in St. John's, Newfoundland, and was a school teacher.^[3] After Patrick and Ellen married and moved to Wisconsin, Doheny's father became a construction laborer and gardener.^[4] As a young fellow, Doheny was known to have consumed alcohol before attending the Peachtree Dance with a local girl he had been courting.^[5]

Doheny graduated from high school in his fifteenth year, and was named the valedictorian of his class.^[6] Following his father's death several months after his graduation, Doheny was employed by the U.S. Geological Survey. In 1873 he was sent to Kansas with a party to survey and subdivide the Kiowa-Comanche lands. The following year he left the Geological Survey to pursue his fortune prospecting, first in the Black Hills of South Dakota,^[1] and then in Arizona Territory and New Mexico Territory.

Doheny is listed in the 1880 United States Census as a painter living in Prescott, Arizona.^[7] Later in 1880, he was in the Black Range in western Sierra County of south-western New Mexico Territory, living in the rough silver-mining town of Kingston (about 10 miles (16 km) west of Hillsboro), prospecting, mining, and buying and trading mining claims. He worked in the famed Iron King mine, just north of Kingston, which drew men to the area. In Kingston, he met two men who later played important roles in his life: Albert Fall, the future Secretary of the Interior, and Charles A. Canfield, who became his business partner.^[8]

Doheny and Canfield together worked the former's Mount Chief Mine with little success.^[8] In 1883, in the Black Mountains town of Kingston in the New Mexico Territory, Doheny met and married his first wife, Carrie Louella Wilkins, on August 7.^[5] In 1886, Canfield prospected further in the Kingston area, leasing and developing with great success the Comstock Mine (not to be confused with the Comstock Lode of Virginia City, Nevada). Doheny declined to join him in this venture, but Canfield made a small fortune from it. Doheny's daughter, Eileen, was born in December 1885.^[5] Doheny was eventually reduced to doing odd jobs (including painting) to support his family.^[9]

In the Spring of 1891, Doheny left New Mexico and moved to Los Angeles, California, attracted by Canfield's success in real estate there. Canfield had previously left New Mexico with $110,000 in cash from his Comstock Mine venture, which he parlayed into extensive real estate holdings during the Los Angeles boom of the later 1880s. With the collapse of the speculative fever, Canfield lost his wealth and land holdings and, by the time Doheny arrived in Los Angeles in 1891, he was deeply in debt.^[10]

The two men briefly tried prospecting in the San Diego County area of Southern California, forming the Pacific Gold and Silver Extracting Company there—but without achieving success, they soon returned to Los Angeles.^[10] By 1892, Doheny was so poor he could not afford to pay for his boarding room.^[11]

Doheny's daughter Eileen was a frail child and died at age seven on December 14, 1892. Her death was caused by heart disease stemming from rheumatic fever, as well as a lung infection.^[12] Edward and Carrie's marriage was fragile, owing mostly to the harsh reality of mining life and their many financial problems.^[13] Eileen's death further strained the marriage. Nearly a year after Eileen's death, on November 6, 1893, Carrie gave birth to their only son Edward Jr., known as Ned.^[14]

While in Los Angeles, Doheny found out that there were local reserves of natural asphalt, which in places came to the surface—notably at the La Brea Tar Pits. Doheny obtained a lease near downtown with $400 in financing from Canfield, who had made some money from the mining industry. In the fall of 1892, Doheny dug a well with picks, shovels, and a windlass, looking for asphalt, from which oil could be refined. When the well (6 by 4 feet (1.8 m × 1.2 m) wide) reached 155 feet (47 m), Doheny devised a drilling system involving a eucalyptus tree trunk.^[11] When completed in 1893, the well reached 225 feet (69 m) and produced 40 barrels per day (6.4 m³/d). (The discovery of this well appears in John Jakes's novel California Gold,—as do Doheny and Canfield, as partners with the novel's fictional protagonist, Mack Chance.)

Edward and Carrie Doheny divorced in 1899, when Ned was six years old.^[15] Edward gained custody of their son, and remarried. Unable to cope with her losses, the following year Carrie Doheny committed suicide.^[16] Doheny married his second wife, Carrie "Estelle" Betzold, inside the private Pullman car of Santa Fe Railway executive Almon Porter Maginnis ("Car 214").^[17] It was held on the siding in New Mexico Territory on August 22, 1900.^[18] Though she bore no children, Carrie raised Ned.^[19]

The first well dug in Los Angeles was in 1863, on Hoover Street between Seventh Street and Wilshire Boulevard, by a man named Baker. However, in his book Petroleum in California: A Concise and Reliable History of the Oil Industry of the State, Lionel V. Redpath says the Los Angeles oil industry began with the Doheny and Canfield well at the corner of Patton and West State streets. The well was a small producer, but it pumped steadily for three years, and during that time Doheny and others sunk about three hundred more wells.^[20] Doheny and Canfield soon made a fortune by drilling in the area and selling the oil to nearby factories. Later, they helped spur the California oil boom of the early 1900s by persuading railroads to switch from coal to oil to power their locomotives.^[11]

Doheny was also a pioneering oil producer in Mexico. In Tampico his company drilled the first well in Mexico in 1901. He expanded operations during the Mexican Revolution, and opened large new oil fields in Mexico's "golden belt" inland from Tampico. It also drilled Cerro Azul No. 4 well—which, in February 1916, became the world's largest-producing well, pumping 260,000 barrels per day (B.P.D.). When the well—drilled by Herbert Wylie—came in, the sound could be heard 16 miles (26 km) away in Casiano, and it shot a stream of oil 598 feet (182 m) into the air, sending oil in a two-mile (three-kilometre) radius. Over the next fourteen years, the well produced over fifty-seven million barrels.^[21]

Doheny formed the Pan American Petroleum and Transport Company (P.A.T.)—part of which later became the Mexican Petroleum Company (Pemex)—to hold his two Mexican companies (Mexican Petroleum and Huasteca), his Atlantic and Gulf Coasts facilities in the United States, and his California holdings.^[21] The company owned 600,000 acres (240,000 ha) of land worth about $50,000,000 and secured an additional 800,000 acres (320,000 ha) in Mexico in October 1919.

In 1919 the Colombian Petroleum Company, a P.A.T. subsidiary, bought a 75% interest in the Barco oil concession in Colombia.^[22] Doheny was also interested in plans to develop the oil industry in Venezuela, and in building a pipeline from Colombia to Venezuela to make it more economical to export the Barco oil from the west coast of Lake Maracaibo.^[23] In 1920 Pan American was the largest oil company in the United States, ahead of Sinclair Consolidated Oil Corporation and Standard Oil Company of Indiana. Automobile production was booming and oil prices were high. The Mexican Petroleum Company was the largest in Mexico, and Mexico was the largest oil producer in the world. By 1925, Doheny's net worth was $100 million ($1.74 billion in 2023 dollars), more at the time than John D. Rockefeller.^[24]

In 1922 Albert B. Fall, U.S. Secretary of the Interior, leased the oil field at Elk Hills, California, to the Pan American Petroleum & Transport Company. Around the same time, the Teapot Dome Field in Wyoming was leased to Sinclair Consolidated Oil Corporation. Both oilfields were part of the US Navy's petroleum reserves. Neither lease was subject to competitive bidding. In 1924 rumors about corruption in the deals escalated into the Teapot Dome scandal.^[25]

Doheny's reputation was somewhat tainted by a bribe paid to the Secretary of the Interior, Albert B. Fall in 1921. He made the "gift" of $100,000 in connection with obtaining a lease of 32,000 acres (13,000 ha) of government-owned land used for the Elk Hills Naval Petroleum Reserve near Taft, California. The resulting scandal broke soon after that, over similar bribes Fall accepted for leasing Teapot Dome in Wyoming. Doheny was charged with bribing Fall but, in 1930, was acquitted. His son, Ned, who had delivered the money, and assistant Hugh Plunkett were also charged, but died before they could be tried.^[26] Nevertheless, Fall was convicted of accepting the bribe.^[27]

Doheny sold a majority of the family's shares in Pan American Petroleum & Transport to Standard Oil of Indiana, in April 1925, but retained all California assets, which he formed into a new company, Pan American Western Petroleum Company. Pan American Eastern Petroleum (the Mexico holdings, the Atlantic and Gulf Coasts holdings in the U.S., refineries, pipelines, and thirty-one tankers), which held the non-California assets, was sold to Standard. Pan American Western returned to its roots as an "upstream" exploration and production company.^[28]

At the end of 1925, in order to exploit the oilfields in Lake Maracaibo Pan American Western gained control of Lago Petroleum Corporation from C. Ledyard Blair's Blair & Co.^[29] The transaction became the subject of a stockholder action in 1933, which alleged that the bankers, who were represented on the Pan American board, conspired to make excessive profits.^[30] In 1926, Venezuelan Eastern Petroleum Corporation reorganized as a subsidiary of Pan American Eastern to buy and develop Venezuelan oil properties.^[31]

In the midst of the Teapot Dome scandal, Doheny gave Greystone Mansion (designed by Gordon B. Kaufmann after a design competition) to his son, Edward (Ned) L. Doheny Jr., and his wife Lucy Marceline Smith (the couple married on June 10, 1914).^[32] He built the 46,000-square-foot (4,300 m²) house in 1928, at a cost of $3,188,000, and sold the property and accompanying 400-acre (1.6 km²) ranch to his son for $10.^[33]

When a second criminal trial for bribery began to loom for Doheny and Fall in 1929, the pressure on all parties reached a breaking point. The Dohenys tried to persuade Hugh Plunkett to be committed to a mental institute so that he could not then be made to testify against them. On February 16 an argument broke out at about 10pm between Ned and Plunkett, Ned shot Plunkett and then himself.^[34] There were rumors that the two were having an affair.^[35] The full story was never clear. The police were not called until three hours after the shots had been fired, despite several members of the family being at home and having heard the yelling. The Los Angeles authorities immediately blamed Plunkett in the murder-suicide. In addition to the indictment of Edward Doheny in the Teapot Dome scandal, both Doheny and Plunkett had been indicted in the alleged bribe of Albert Fall—as Ned (accompanied by Plunkett) had delivered the money. They had already gone through some trials.^[36]

Raymond Chandler, a former oil man, included a thinly veiled account of this event in one chapter of his novel The High Window, presenting it as a bygone, hushed-up case. He had started work for the Dabney Oil Syndicate in 1922 as a bookkeeper and auditor, but was fired a decade later.^[37]

Beset by shareholder lawsuits in the wake of Teapot Dome, and the death of Ned, Doheny became a recluse and invalid.^[38] When she realized her husband needed an undisturbed home away for a while after the Teapot Dome travails and Ned's death, Carrie Estelle asked architect Wallace Neff to design and build the Ferndale Ranch complex on their Ojai, California property.^[39] Hundreds of workers completed the 9,000 square feet (840 m²) house in less than six weeks, including Neff's blueprints, by working day and night.^[33][40]

Edward L. Doheny died at his Beverly Hills townhouse on September 8, 1935, of natural causes, a month after his seventy-ninth birthday.^[1] His funeral was in St. Vincent's Church in Los Angeles.^[41] That year Carrie Estelle Doheny, Doheny's widow, burned hundreds of letters and business documents, what biographer Margaret Leslie Davis describes as the "written remnants of Edward Doheny's life" (p. 4).^[36]

Doheny contributed money to foundations. He helped fund the construction of St. Vincent de Paul Church. After the shooting death of his son, Edward Jr., he donated $1.1 million in 1932 to the University of Southern California (USC) to build the Edward L. Doheny Jr. Memorial Library.^[42]

Doheny Sr., meanwhile, lived in his own mansion, which he had purchased in 1901.^[43] It was part of Chester Place, a gated community of Victorian mansions, and by his death in 1935, Doheny ended up owning most of the houses, as well as the street.^[33] Built in 1899 in the French Gothic architectural style, this three-story, twenty-two-room residence was damaged in the 1933 earthquake but was repaired. It is within Mount Saint Mary's University's Doheny campus, where it houses college departments, runs docent tours, and hosts chamber music concerts by The Da Camera Society.^{[citation needed]}

The Dohenys also owned a great deal of coastal land in Dana Point, California, which they donated to the State of California for Doheny State Beach as a memorial to Edward's murdered son Ned. They also donated the funds for the construction of St. Edward the Confessor Roman Catholic Church at its original site. It has since moved to a bluff-top location overlooking Doheny State Beach. The original building is now home to San Felipe de Jesus Roman Catholic Church.^{[citation needed]}

After he began basing his Mexican oil operations near Tampico, Tamaulipas in 1902, Doheny donated much money toward the construction and maintenance of the Cathedral of Tampico there. Also known as The Temple of the Immaculate Conception, it is located in Plaza de Armas in the city. The Doheny Estate has donated money to Loyola Marymount University for the construction of buildings and residence halls, and the land for one of the campuses of Mount St. Mary's College south of downtown Los Angeles.^{[citation needed]}

Doheny took his yacht, the Casiana (named after his first major producing oil well in Mexico, the Casiana No. 7), to Martinique to pick up a friend's brother who worked as a farmer on the island and who was seriously ill. Doheny brought him back to New York City; the steam yacht made the trip in only five days.^{[citation needed]}

In 1944, his widow Carrie Estelle Doheny suffered a hemorrhage that left her partially blind. Realizing the value of good vision, she created and funded the Doheny Eye Institute,^[44] which has become a world leader in vision research. She became a major cultural philanthropist in Los Angeles, California as well. When commissioning new buildings for these civic projects, she often chose the renowned Southern California architect Wallace Neff. On her death, she left antiquities and funds to St. John's (Roman Catholic) Seminary located in Camarillo, in Ventura County.^{[citation needed]}

In 1954, Estelle Doheny provided funds and "a quantity of her precious collections in the library building" at St. Mary's of the Barrens seminary in Perryville, Missouri.^[45] By November 11, 2000, the Vincentian Fathers signed a contract with Southeast Missouri State University to use the library building. So, "the Doheny treasures were sold."^[45]

Doheny and his first wife, Carrie Louella, had a daughter, Eileen, who died in childhood. Their son, Edward L. ("Ned") Doheny Jr., was the owner of Greystone Mansion and the namesake of Doheny Library at the University of Southern California.

Through Ned's children, Doheny is the great-grandfather of science fiction writer Larry Niven^[46] and singer-songwriter Ned Doheny.^[47]

Numerous place names in Southern California are named for him:

• Doheny Drive in West Hollywood and Beverly Hills
• Doheny Road in Beverly Hills
• Doheny Circle in Irvine
• Doheny State Beach, on the Pacific coast of Orange County, in Dana Point
• The Edward Laurence Doheny Memorial Library at St. John's Seminary, Camarillo, California. (The Carrie Estelle Doheny Memorial Library at the same institution commemorates his widow.)
• Doheny Mansion, on Mount Saint Mary's University

• Doheny's payment to Albert Fall and the scandal inspired Upton Sinclair's novel, Oil!, based in part on Doheny's life.^[11]
• Reference to Doheny Beach, in the Beach Boys song "Surfin' USA". Lyrical verse "...all over Manhattan and down Doheny way, everybody's gone surfin', surfin' USA."^[48]
• In the movie There Will Be Blood, an adaptation of the novel Oil!, the character of Daniel Plainview portrayed by Daniel Day-Lewis is loosely based on Doheny.
• In the 1964 Jan and Dean hit song, "Dead Man's Curve", the lyrics read, "He passed me at Doheny, then I started to swerve...."^[49]
• Lydell McCutcheon, a character in "Perry Mason" (season two), is loosely based on Doheny.^[50]

• Ansell, Martin R. (1998). Oil Baron of the Southwest: Edward L. Doheny and the Development of the Petroleum Industry in California and Mexico. Columbus, Ohio: Ohio State University Press. ISBN 0-8142-0749-9. — A standard scholarly biography.
• Davis, Margaret Leslie (1998). Dark Side of Fortune: Triumph and Scandal in the Life of Oil Tycoon Edward L. Doheny. Berkeley: University of California Press. ISBN 0-520-22909-6. — A standard scholarly biography.
• Gross, Dalton; Gross, MaryJean (1998-01-01). Understanding The Great Gatsby: A Student Casebook to Issues, Sources, and Historical Documents. Greenwood Publishing Group. ISBN 978-0-313-30097-4.
• La Botz, Dan (1991). Edward L. Doheny: Petroleum, Power and Politics in the United States and Mexico. New York: Praeger. ISBN 0-275-93599-X. — Poorly received by reviewers who noted many errors and oversights.
• Swaine, Robert T. (1946). The Cravath Firm And Its Predecessors: 1819-1947. The Lawbook Exchange, Ltd. ISBN 978-1-58477-713-7.

• Doheny Mansion
• Edward L. Doheny Jr.. Memorial Library at USC
• "Text of Edward L. Doheny Jr. Memorial Library"
• Family retreat in Franklin Canyon
• "Edward L. Doheny". Find a Grave. Retrieved September 3, 2010.
• Edward L. Doheny in libraries (WorldCat catalog)
• Newspaper clippings about Edward L. Doheny in the 20th Century Press Archives of the ZBW